InThinking Revision Sites

INTHINKING REVISION SITES

Own your learning

Why not also try our independent learning self-study & revision websites for students?

We currenly offer the following DP Sites: Biology, Chemistry, English A Lang & Lit, Maths A&A, Maths A&I, Physics, Spanish B

"The site is great for revising the basic understandings of each topic quickly. Especially since you are able to test yourself at the end of each page and easily see where yo need to improve."

"It is life saving... I am passing IB because of this site!"

Basic (limited access) subscriptions are FREE. Check them out at:

Globalization and behaviour

Globalization and behaviour

After completing this lesson, you should be able to:

  • Discuss one example of how globalization may affect mental health and subjective well-being
  • Explain research that shows both the positive and negative effects of globalization.
  • Explain how local and global cultural factors may interact to affect mental health and subjective well-being

Key concepts

Before completing the module below, please read the section of the textbook called Globalization and behaviour. When reading this section, please make note of the following important concepts:

  • Acculturative stress
  • Emic vs etic approaches
  • Hikikomori
  • Integration
  • Marginalization

The globalization of mental illness

Watch the following video where Ethan Watters talks about his book "Crazy Like Us" in which he discusses the globalization of Western mental illness and treatment.

Then read through the presentation below.  The presentation is based on Ethan Watters research on globalization of depression in Japan.

 

Emic vs Etic approaches

Globalization takes an etic approach to understanding mental illness, whereas Ethan Watters discusses an emic approach to mental illness.  What is the difference?

An etic approachAn emic approach
  • A deductive approach - in this case, based on Western understandings of mental illness.
  • Tests used by psychologists are standardized materials used in Western diagnosis, known to have high reliability in that population.
  • The goal is to apply findings from Western culture to resolve problems in other cultures.
  • Uses "professionals" trained in psychology to carry out diagnosis and treatment.
  • An inductive approach - in this case, based on local understandings of mental illness.
  • Tests are adapted or created based on feedback from specialists within the local culture.
  • The goal is to treat the mental health problem in the community that is being studied.
  • Uses local knowledge provided by members of the community - including religious leaders and indigenous healing practitioners in order to help diagnose and treat mental health problems.

Thinking about research

Two key studies that may be used to discuss the role of globalization on behaviour are Norasakkunkit & Uchida (2014)'s study of Hikikomori and Becker et al (2002)'s study of eating disorders. Both of these studies show negative aspects of globalization. However, not all of the effects are negative.  Novotny and Polonsky (2011) have shown that globalization may have positive effects on behaviour as well.

For each of the studies fill in the following grid. To fill in the grid, be sure to go to FILE and choose to MAKE A COPY.

Checking for understanding

Yukiko enjoys working for an international company in Tokyo.  This month, she was given the award for being "employee of the month."  She often gives advice to her boss and she enjoys the independence her boss gives her to pursue her own projects.  When she goes home to her family, she struggles with having to be the "obedient daughter" and is often resentful of the demands that her family puts on her.  According to Berry's acculturation model, which acculturation strategy is she displaying?

Yukiko is showing that she has a positive attitude about the globalized culture but a negative attitude toward her local culture.  This is an example of assimilation.

 

Which of the following is an example of an emic approach to understanding mental illness in Rwanda after the genocide?

When Western psychologists use local expertise to solve a problem, rather than relying on Western "truths", this is an emic approach.  Although translating a test into Kinyarwanda is helpful for the local culture, it is still the same Western test, and so it is still an etic approach.

 

John studied Mandarin at university.  Now he has taken his first job working for a Chinese pharmaceutical company.  He is finding it very difficult to adapt to his new work environment.  He feels that decisions are rather top-down and that there is not enough discussion about major decisions.  He also feels that management is often intrusive in his personal life. He knows he has only been there for about a month, but he is really struggling with his work.  What do psychologists call this?

John is going through a bit of culture shock - what psychologists call acculturative stress.  He will need to adopt to the Chinese culture if he is going to be successful in his new job.  If he were delocalized, he would be rejecting his own culture.  If he were marginalized, he would feel that he didn't belong in either his own culture or in the Chinese culture.  Identity confusion is linked to marginalization.

 

According to Kirmayer, cultures have different ways of understanding mental illness - there is not a universal understanding of mental illness.  What does Kirmayer call these local understandings?

Explanatory models are ways that cultures explain mental illness.  Watters talks about this when he says that Americans often see mental illness as occurring in their mind; whereas non-Western cultures often see such illness affecting their social relations. Some cultures also believe that mental illness is the result of outside influences - such as spirits or unfulfilled family obligations.

 

Which of the following did not play a key role in the Japanese adoption of the Western understanding of depression?

Although it is theoretically possible that Japanese doctors trained overseas would play a role in this change, it was the media that played the greatest role in convincing the Japanese that depression was not healthy - and they could do something about it.

 

Which of the following is not a symptom used to diagnose hikikomori?

Although Internet addiction and online gaming are often what we see fills the days of hikokomori, it is not a symptom of the disorder.

 

In Norasakkunkit & Uchida's (2014) study, which word describes the characteristic of the Hikikomori students that they studied?

The local culture may alienate many Japanese youths who may then decide not to conform to the cultural norms, but do not identify with or know how to access the globalized culture, and so they withdraw from society.

 

In Norasakkunkit & Uchida's (2014) study, they did not study participants with an actual diagnosis of hikikomori.  Instead, they use students who self-reported many of the symptoms that hikikomori display. What type of study is this?

Analogous studies use people that are similar to those that have the disorder but have not been diagnosed.  This type of research is often done in abnormal psychology to avoid ethical issues, but there is a concern that the samples may not be generalizable to people who actually have the disorder.

 

Which research method was used in Becker et al's (2002) study of eating disorders in Fiji?

The study was a natural experiment.  The introduction of Western television was the independent variable - but this was not manipulated by the researcher.

 

To what extent can we use Becker et al's (2002) study to support the theory that globalization has led to a rise in eating disorders?

None of the girls in the study were actually diagnosed with a disorder, but there was an increase in "eating disorder related behaviours" over the course of the study.

 

Novotny and Polansky (2011) used which research method to investigate the link between globalization and tolerance of Muslims in the Czech Republic and Slovakia?

The researchers compared the participants' scores on questionnaires about their knowledge of Islam and their attitudes toward Muslims.  No variables were manipulated and there was no IV.

 

What was the key finding of Novotny and Polansky's (2011) study?

Participants with more knowledge did not see Islam as a threat to their own identity or culture. In this particular study, there is very little Muslim immigration to the Czech Republic and Slovakia, so knowing a Muslim played a minimal role in tolerance in these countries.

 

Total Score:

Continue on to Globalization: Research methods