Presentation: Cognition and MDD
The following presentation supports the study of the cognitive etiologies of Major Depressive Disorder
You are not expected to learn all of the material in this presentation. When using this study for revision, remember to:
- Focus on key concepts
- Learn 2 - 3 studies that you feel you understand. You may also, instead, learn studies from the textbook or from your teacher.
- Focus on key evaluation points
Evaluation of cognitive etiologies
Strengths
CBT, a therapy based on Beck's theory, has been highly successful in treating patients.
There is a wide variety of research that supports the thinking patterns of people living with depression.
There is biological support (e.g. Farb et al) for the theory of rumination.
Helps to explain gender differences in the prevalence of depression.
Explains the role of cognitive processes as mitigating factors in depression - explaining both depression and resilience to stressful life events.
Limitations
Question of bidirectional ambiguity: depression can make thinking more negative, and negative thinking can probably cause and certainly worsen depression
It is not possible to isolate cognitive factors from biological and social factors.
Nolen-Hoeksema's theory has been challenged for temporal validity. Has society changed over time and made the theory less valid?
It is not possible to accurately measure "rumination" or "maladaptive schema."
The Treatment Aetiology fallacy - that is, the mistaken notion that the success of a given form of treatment reveals the cause of the disorder