Ideas for Internal Assessment
The following list is made up of potential studies for replication for the internal assessment. It is by no means a definitive list of all the topics that students could choose to explore. Students should choose something that they clearly understand and is easy to replicate.
However, it is required that they only have one independent variable, so some of the studies below will have to be simplified, looking at only one aspect of the study. Students may, however, have more than one level of an independent variable, as long as you have taught them the statistics to determine the significance of their data (most likely a chi-squared or ANOVA).
Memory studies
Baddeley et al (1975). The word length effect - how the length of a word affects free recall.
Bower et al (1969) two groups of participants were presented with a list of words. For one group the words were in a random order, whereas for the other group they were arranged under categories. After looking at the list, participants were asked to recall as many words as they could remember. Participants who had the organized lists recalled significantly more words than participants who had random lists.
Bransford, J.D. & Johnson, M. K. (1972). A study of how schema affect memory. This study looked at whether hearing a title before a passage is read would actually affect the amount of the passage that would be recalled. There is more than one version in the original paper. Students may, of course, write their own passage to make it more relevant to their participants.
Coltheart (1992) Testing the Working Memory Model. The extent to which phonological similarity of words impairs short-term memory recall. Concurrent irrelevant articulation lowered recall and abolished the phonological similarity effect for both repeated and novel word lists.
Etnier & Labban (2011). This is a great study for students who are interested in sport and exercise. The original study had three conditions: exercise before, exercise after, and no exercise while listening to a prose paragraph. Only the exercise performance condition showed significantly higher performance on recall.
Kargopoulos, Bablekou, Gonida and Kiosseoglou (2003). A study that shows when information is paired with a photograph, memory is better than when it is matched with text only.
Loftus and Palmer (1974). Participants asked how fast cars were going when they smashed into each other, after viewing a car accident, report greater speeds than do participants asked the speed when they ‘hit’ each other.
Mandler (1967) In one of Mandler’s studies, participants were given 52 cards with a randomly selected word on each card, they were then asked to sort the cards into between 2 – 7 categories of their choice. They were then asked to recall as many words as they could remember. The more categories the participants had used, the higher their recall of words.
Miller (1956). The original chunking experiment is difficult to replicate as the original study is rather difficult for most students to read. But we are allowed to base our studies on an original study or theory, so this link is a good idea for how to set up an experiment to test Miller's theory of the Magic 7.
Paivio (1971). Imagery vs rehearsal: participants recall more words from a (20) word list when they use an imagery method (forming a vivid mental image and linking each item to the last in a dynamic fashion) than if they use either rehearsal (repeat each item until you hear the next) or no particular method (no prior instruction).
Perham & Vizard (2010) Does background music impair memory? Serial recall was tested under quiet, liked, and disliked music sound conditions as well as steady-state (repetition of ‘3’) and changing-state speech (random digits 1–9). Results revealed performance to be poorer for both music conditions and the changing-state speech compared to quiet and steady-state speech conditions.
Peterson & Peterson (1959, p. 194) In the memory task, the participant viewed a trigram of consonants (e.g., GKT, WCH,...) and then performed a number of algebraic computations (e.g., counting backwards by 3s) for less than 20 seconds. The data showed that recall of the trigram was less likely as the participant worked on the algebraic computations for longer durations.
Rogers, Kuiper and Kirker (1977). A different aspect of levels of processing theory - this looks at what happens when we make a personal connection to what we are learning - the effect of self-referencing. A sample of a replication of this study can be found here.
Other areas of research
Ariely, Loewenstein and Prezlec (2005). Participants are asked to fill in a “group number” on their papers. One group is given a low 2-digit number (e.g. 13) and the second is given a higher value (e.g. 97). Then the participants are asked to consider whether they would pay x number of dollars for items whose value they did not know, such as wine, chocolate and computer equipment. They were then asked to bid for these items, with the result that the participants with higher two-digit numbers would submit bids that were between 60 percent and 120 percent higher than those with the lower numbers, which had become their anchor.
Carmon and Ariely (2000) A study of the endowment effect - when we value something more when it is ours.
Elliot et al (2007). The effect of the colour red on the ability to solve anagrams. The argument is that the colour red impairs processing because it is associated with danger.
Jonides and Gleitman (1972). Word and letter recognition: Visual search: Participants will take longer to find 0 among letters if it is called zero than when it is called the letter ‘oh’ and vice versa.
Kruger, Wirtz, Van Boven, and Altermatt (2004). A series of experiments on the effort effect - the idea that we tend to assign more value to something that took more effort. In one of the experiments, participants were asked to evaluate the quality of two paintings by Deborah Kleven: 12 Lines and Big Abstract. Half of the participants were told that the former took 4 hours to paint and the latter 26 hours and the other half were told the opposite. The results showed that participants preferred 12 Lines over Big Abstract when they thought 12 Lines took longer to paint, but the opposite tended to be true when they thought that Big Abstract took longer to paint.
Nisbett and Wilson (1977) The halo effect states that attractive people are perceived as having more positive attributes. For a summary of the classic experiment, click here.
Pachur and Biele (2007) A study of the recognition heuristic. When asked to make predictions about which team would win in a competition, the name that was more familiar is more often chosen.
Strack and Mussweiler (1997) A study in anchoring effect. There are actually several studies in this paper. From the online textbook, you will find the study where participants are asked to estimate Gandhi's age at the time of his death - both with plausible and implausible anchors.
Stroop effect (Stroop 1935) The classic study of interference between system 1 and system 2 processing.
Triplett (1898) Social Facilitation Theory - The idea is that people tend to perform better when in groups than when on their own. Participants can be given tasks (e.g. word searches) either in groups or on their own to test this theory.
Tversky and Kahneman (1973) A study of the availability heuristic. If people recall more items from one set than from another they assume that there actually were more in the former set. Demonstrate this by giving participants a set of names to remember containing 19 very famous males and 20 not so famous females. Since participants tend to recall more male names they tend to judge that more males were on the list.
Tversky and Kahneman (1974) A study of anchoring bias. This paper has a series of different studies of the anchoring effect. For example, 10! in ascending and descending order.
Weinstein (1980). A study in optimism bias. Participants were asked to rate how likely various life events were to happen to them, relative to their classmates. The results were that participants thought that good events were more likely to happen to them, while bad events were more likely to happen to other students.
Williams and Bargh (2008) Does reading something about old age make you walk more slowly? A study of priming that has been very much challenged. Here is also a good article on the original study.