Date | May 2017 | Marks available | 6 | Reference code | 17M.1.BP.TZ0.3 |
Level | Both SL and HL | Paper | Paper 1 - first exams 2017 | Time zone | TZ0 |
Command term | Compare and contrast | Question number | 3 | Adapted from | N/A |
Question
The sources and questions relate to Case study 1: Genghis Khan c1200–1227 – Campaigns: Mongol invasion of China: attacks on the Jin dynasty; capture of Beijing (1215).
Source C
Frank McLynn, a military historian, writing in an academic biography, Genghis Khan: His conquests, His empire, His legacy (Dschingis Khan: Seine Eroberungen, sein Imperium, sein Vermächtnis) (2015).
The three pitched battles fought in September 1211 destroyed the Jin as a credible battlefield force. It is difficult to convey the extent of the Chinese losses at battles such as Badger Mouth, but nine years later travellers reported the fields of carnage still covered with bones. At the imperial court Chih-Chung was widely blamed for the disaster. It was said that he was too timid, that he should have attacked the Mongols with cavalry alone, and much earlier while they were still pillaging, but that he insisted on fighting with both cavalry and infantry on the field …
Genghis ordered Jebe to take Chu-yung chuan, a fortified pass. Jebe found Nankou, the town at the end of the pass, too strong to be taken by assault so he pretended to retreat. All along the fifteen-mile pass were fortresses perched on steep slopes. At news of Jebe’s retreat the soldiers all rushed out, eager to be in at the kill. Jebe led them on a chase for thirty-five miles, stretching them out so that the various groups of pursuers lost touch with each other. Then he turned and demolished them one group at a time, spreading panic that in the end led the defenders of Chu-yung chuan to surrender to the Mongols.
Early in November Genghis and the main army marched down the pass and pitched camp twenty miles from Peking [Beijing], accepting the surrender of three other important fortresses.
The sources and questions relate to Case study 1: Genghis Khan c1200–1227 – Campaigns: Mongol invasion of China: attacks on the Jin dynasty; capture of Beijing (1215).
Source A
An anonymous author, writing for the Mongol royal family after Genghis Khan’s death, in The Secret history of the Mongols (c14th century).
Genghis Khan set out to fight the people of north China. First he took the city of Fuzhou then marching through the Wild Fox Pass he took the city of Xuandefu. From here he sent out an army under Jebe’s command to take the fortress of Zhuyongguan.
When Jebe arrived there he saw that it was well defended, so he said “I’ll trick them and make them come out in the open. I’ll pretend to retreat and when they come out, I’ll attack them.” So Jebe retreated and the north Chinese army cried “Let’s go after them!” They poured out of their fortifications until the valleys and mountainsides were full of their soldiers. Jebe retreated to Sondi-i-wu Ridge and there he turned his army round to attack as the enemy rushed towards him in waves.
The north Chinese army was beaten. Close behind Jebe’s forces came Genghis Khan, commanding the great Middle Army. They too attacked, forcing the north Chinese army to retreat.
Compare and contrast what Sources A and C reveal about the Jin defeats in 1211.
Markscheme
Apply the markbands that provide the “best fit” to the responses given by candidates and award credit wherever it is possible to do so. The following material is an indication of what candidates may elect to write about in their responses. It is neither prescriptive nor exhaustive and no set answer is required.
Indicative content
Comparisons:
- Both sources highlight that the Jin were defeated despite having strong fortifications/defences.
- Both sources comment on the army pretending to retreat in order to draw out the defenders and then to attack them.
- Both sources highlight Genghis Khan’s role in sending Jebe to attack the Jin and in leading the main section of the Mongol army.
Contrasts:
- Source C blames Chih-Chung for Jin defeats whereas Source A indicates that the strengths of Genghis Khan and the Mongols are the reason for the outcome.
- Source C comments on Genghis Khan “accepting the surrender” of other fortresses whereas Source A presents him as having a more active fighting role in additional attacks after Jebe’s victory.
- Source A comments on the Jin army retreating whereas Source C comments on the Jin army surrendering.